Shakespeare set Romeo and Juliet in Verona, and the city has been living off the favor ever since. The most visited thing here, a balcony, is a 20th-century assembly of old stone, and we'll say so when we get to it. The good news is that Verona doesn't need the invented parts. It has a Roman arena that still hosts an opera audience, the Scaliger family, who ruled the city in the 13th and 14th centuries and left their tombs in the middle of town, a Romanesque basilica, a castle that Carlo Scarpa turned into one of Italy's best-designed museums, and a river that bends around the old center like a moat.
Verona is small, and that's the problem with how most people visit it. Day-trippers arrive by late morning, the crowd jams Via Cappello and Piazza delle Erbe, and by dinner it has thinned out. Five days lets you do the sights in the quiet hours, eat properly, and spend a full day on Lake Garda. We weighed two day trips. Garda wins: Sirmione is 43 km away and easy by train and bus. Valpolicella, the Amarone country, goes under "more time" because the wineries are spread over hills the trains don't reach, and you can drink the wine in town.
The plan gives every day one area. Day one is the Arena, Juliet's House and Piazza delle Erbe, day two the Scaliger squares, the churches and the Roman bridge, day three Castelvecchio and San Zeno, day four Sirmione on Lake Garda, and day five the Giusti garden, the quiet east bank and a last dinner. Start on a Tuesday: the Arena, Castelvecchio and the city's other civic museums are closed on Mondays (Juliet's House opens only in the afternoon), and the churches only open in the afternoon on Sundays. For the wider picture, see our page on Italy.